I actually didn't like the AE. I thought most of what they added was unnecessary at best or downright annoying at worst. It was certainly harder than the standard edition, no doubt about that, but not in any way that was more interesting or fun. All it really did was add a million more ways for things to go wrong - and since your ships did not have larger capacities for gear than they have in the standard edition, there was no way to effectively plan, counter, or prepare for any of it. Ultimately the RNG was emboldened, whereas tactics and skill were far less important. Slot Machine: Advanced Edition was my impression of it. It didn't matter how well you played, because, as you described, you could be trundling along and doing really well, then suddenly find yourself up against a weapons you have no defense against, which succinctly wipes out your crew and most of your systems.
The standard edition felt more balanced to me in this regard. Granted, the RNG was always lurking like a voracious predator, but it had a few less teeth in its sinister maw. Making good decisions actually mattered, whereas in the AE it seemed like the only route to success was if you got really, really lucky.
Great review, though. Reading it makes me want to re-install it and play it again, though I'll probably stick to the standard edition if I do.
placid like acid