This tale of tragedy and triumph might lack anything resembling a conclusive ending, but it does possess a beginning. Late in 2021, I started playing Nioh — a Souls-like developed by Team Ninja and Kou Shibusawa for Koei Tecmo. The reasoning behind this decision was simple. I’m addicted to that sub-genre of games and Nioh was amongst the best-reviewed of FROM’s imitators.
Based very, very loosely on real people and events, this game puts you in control of European samurai William Adams as he gets in involved in 1600s Japanese history while pursuing an evil wizard using evil magic to summon all sorts of evil creatures to raise all kinds of havoc in a country dealing with minor things like feudal warlords battling each other in an attempt to be the nation’s ruling power.
Everything starts with a tutorial level set in the Tower of London, as William breaks free from captivity and slays his way through the place, culminating with a battle against a massive executioner whom, midway through the confrontation, transforms into a half-human, half-demon monster. Since this is a Souls-like, it won’t be like a regular tutorial. There are a few tough fights that are made more difficult due to how there’s no way to gain levels and while the boss might be slow with predictable movements, he is powerful enough to emphatically punish carelessness.
From there, William heads to Japan and embarks on a series of adventures. Nioh is divided into a series of stand-alone levels, as opposed to possessing a world where everything is connected somehow, with optional side-quests opening up upon completing those stages. In another departure from the norm, this game also uses a Diablo-inspired loot system, where weapons and armor regularly are dropped by fallen foes, leading to you possessing a crowded inventory — at least until you visit a shrine and convert all that stuff into experience in hopes of gaining another level.
Now, more in line with the usual Souls experience, gaining those levels only gives William very minor improvements. He’ll gain power more quickly by regularly swapping out old equipment for new, as well as attaining new talents and spells. In fact, for the most part, I was having the experience I was expecting. Gradual, steady progress though the stages with the occasional roadblock at a boss until I’d either gained a bit more power or became more proficient at handling its attack patterns.
Credit: Team Ninja/Sony Interactive Entertainment/Koei TecmoAnd things continued in this way for some time. Sure, some bosses were utterly hateful and I struggled to maintain interest in those side-quests because many of them simply recycled parts of stages with different challenges to overcome, but I was progressing through places that reminded me of stuff I was used to from playing various Souls games. There were caves, villages, tombs and even a flooded level where I had to diligently watch where I walked, lest I plummet to a watery grave. Meanwhile, I learned how to fight most everything. You had basic soldiers and undead, as well as a number of large, demonic foes possessing a variety of attacks. Maybe I never felt comfortable taking on the swift and deadly Raven Tengu, but the more common ones like the Yoki typically were pretty easy to topple.
Then, in early 2022, adversity struck. The level itself — two-thirds of the way through the game — wasn’t anything that bad: A village and mansion that were on fire, making it important to watch where I was walking. However, the boss was pure hell for my usual MASSIVE MELEE POWER style of play. This dude was nimble, quick and could use his magical abilities to fly in the air, often disabling my ability to lock onto him in the process. To make a long story short, this dude killed me a couple dozen times, Elden Ring was released and I decided I’d rather play FROM’s shiny new toy than continue struggling through this hell. The end.
Until this year! For some reason, my brain went back to Nioh and I started wondering just where I went wrong. Perusing the Internet, I found two possible solutions. First, I read a lot of comments from people stating that this game’s designers designed combat a bit differently from FROM, so a player who relied on the same “roll away from danger” tactics that carried them through those games would regularly get punished. Secondly, in my zeal to focus on MASSIVE MELEE POWER with the gigantic Odachi sword, I was neglecting magic and some of those abilities can be abused to turn brutal challenges into guaranteed victories.
One magical skill was able to greatly deplete an enemy’s attack power. Another, quite overpowered, ability allowed me to cut a foe’s movement speed in half, making it child’s play to avoid their attacks and then lunge in to deliver combos without fear of reprisal. In order to build up my magic so the effect of those abilities would last longer, I simply replayed every single mission I’d completed and put every level I gained into magic. By the time I got back to where I’d stalled, I was able to quickly dispatch its boss and just like that, I was able to resume progression through the game.
That momentum carried me through the rest of the game. I’m not going to lie and say I had no problems making it to the end, but I was able to eventually overcome any and all challenges. After beating the final boss, I only had to go through the three DLC chapters and I’d be able to call my time with Nioh a resounding triumph!
And so I started up the first one and found the opposition was far tougher than in the base game. The basic soldiers were stronger and more durable, while a new class of demon had a grab attack that, if it connected, could instantly kill me. Back to the Internet…
Credit: Team Ninja/Sony Interactive Entertainment/Koei TecmoThis time, the solution was simple. Back when the DLC was first released, gamers already had access to the first of what eventually became several New Game Plus runs and the general consensus was that taking advantage of that would be a big help in playing through the DLC. And so I did about two-thirds of the game again in New Game Plus, gained more levels, obtained superior equipment and had all kinds of success in the first DLC.
Well, at least until I fought its final boss, the speedy, aggressive and amazingly powerful Maria. This girl was absolutely brutal, especially to a guy decked out in heavy armor who is trying to wave around a massive sword. Oftentimes, my attempts to cast my magic would utterly fail because she’d be stabbing me in the face before that action could be completed and, even if I was successful at slowing her down, that effect didn’t last for long. I was at a loss.
And then I found out that I could just skip ahead to the next DLC without completing the first. My plan was simple: Fight as far through the rest of the bonus content as I could and, with the extra power I accrued, challenge Maria again. That plan lasted all the way until I met the first boss of that second DLC — a ninja who’s, if anything, quicker than Maria. His individual attacks might not have been that bad, but when he’s hitting you constantly and it feels impossible to cast a spell, reliably heal yourself or even dodge him, that’s not much of a consolation now, is it? The end, part two.
I suppose the main thing I learned from Nioh is that my typical one-dimensional MASSIVE MELEE POWER style wasn’t necessarily suited to it. Sure, it worked just fine in getting through levels, but then often turned into a liability against bosses, as those foes regularly possessed of speed, power and aggression in sufficient qualities to transform my powerhouse into a bumbling, flailing oaf. And it wasn’t like that heavy, cumbersome armor was providing sufficient protection to justify it weighing me down — this is a Souls-like, after all!
But, regardless of how frustrated I got with Nioh, I do have to admit that it did find a way to dig its claws into me. After four years, I put it back into my PS4 and spent a ton of time with it in order to finish the main game and I can see me giving it another shot a few years from now in an attempt to finish the job with the DLC. While its combat might not adhere to FROM’s formula as closely as I’d desire, it does provide the same sort of intense challenge that I love from this sort of game. And apparently love so much that I’ll put myself through months of hell just so I can enjoy that moment of triumph that results from finally being able to see the credits roll.

