"Of course if you like to be a nit picking critical douche when it comes to PS3 exclusives then sure you can find faults with this game(*cough*like the reviewer*cough*)"
lol.. I can find faults with I2 as well, and I'm the ps3 fanboy around here. But yeah, being critical on one hand, and looking for faults to criticise the game for are two different things.
But I think that it's important to remember that every one of us have our own perspective on things, though. Like you do, and hopefully everyone else.
And on this site we tend to, at least, to think of a review as successful if it explains why and how the reviewer came to their point of view. Whether you agree or disagree with the conclusion or the grade isn't important.
So criticising the review could be things such as mentioning how it could be missing a perspective that should be thought of as important in the context of the review as it was written, maybe? Is it consistent, and does it gloss over parts of the game to be so? Those are things you don't want to do, and I'm sure every critic will be thankful if mistakes like that are pointed out (even if we will deny it forever).
Or it could be a different perspective you have, where you see the experience from a completely different angle. For example, lately a lot of people have started to talk warmly about Moonstone again. This is a technically horrible game, actually, and it isn't easy to play. And once you figure it out, you could suddenly start to have a too easy time with the fights, etc. And if you explain how the game goes from a to b, it's incredibly difficult to explain it as a good game.
But a lot of people, and me too, still think it is one of the best games ever made - and that it still is a good game now that graphics and so on are better - because of the unique way it makes your imagination fly off, and in the way it engages you and makes you think.
So you might say, well your review wasn't exactly completely self-explanatory either, and that's the problem, right? Maybe the way I grew up on Tolkien, Beowulf, Old Norse sagas and faery tales has something to do with how easily I slip into something like this. Maybe it's not as complicated as that - that it's something.. er.. distinctly "continental" about the wizards, stonehenge, and the knights - that makes me relate to the setting in that game very easily. You could say the same for Demon's Souls, for example.
But I'm having a very hard time saying that this is a game you should like because you think Dragons are awesome, or something like that. It becomes extremely difficult to end up there.
In the same way, maybe there are things about other games that I can't relate to at all that fascinates others.
So in the end, like everyone else, I'm just trying to explain my perspective. Not trying to tell everyone else what to think.. I think. And then perhaps spark someone's interest if they relate to those thoughts. I mean, we're not IGN either.
There is something to say about how reviewing tends to become irrelevant, once it completely becomes only opinion, though. In the sense that when you read the review, you know that the review is pretty much positive or negative depending on the reviewer's mood, instead of how the game actually plays..
Then we're in trouble.