Psychopenguin: While I didn't think that this was one of true's stronger reviews, I'm not sure what prompted your vicious response to the text and to the quality control standards this site.
Yes, the bit about calling the game out for not having an intuitive battle system is strange given how unique it feels (there are many who have trouble adapting to it after playing many of the other RPGs that true seems to feel it copies), but true probably just didn't place as much significance on those innovations or adapted to them quickly enough that he didn't see them as special. Similarly, his decision to not comment on a late-game twist that you felt was significant also speaks to his differing perspective... or perhaps just an attempt to avoid spoiler territory. In any event, it's clear that he wasn't as sucked into the plot as you were, so a betrayal by the writers at the end probably wouldn't have hit him as hard.
After reading the review, my impression was that true probably just thinks the alchemy system in this one is epic because he hasn't played the numerous other RPGs that incorporate deep alchemy systems (including numerous Atelier Iris games that preceded Mana Khemia, and possibly the Ar Tonelico titles). As someone who has played a few alchemy games, I was disappointed that he didn't cover ground that would have let me know where this game stands compared to those. Even so, the review did a good job of summing up what made the game worth playing for true. It's sure to resonate with its target audience: other people who are looking for a great new RPG to try and who may share his inexperience with alchemy-heavy RPGs. They'll probably find much of the text illuminating. Not everyone has experienced a bunch of alchemy RPGs, after all!
The worst sin this review is guilty of is the occasional oversight. I see no attempt to mislead. It doesn't deserve the thrashing it got. If anything, it deserves a well-reasoned response that perhaps examines other aspects of the game. Your response leaves me thinking that in this case, you're probably not the person to provide that. I hope that you'll continue to respond to reviews in the future, whether you agree or disagree, but I hope that you'll do so courteously. There are some sites where a person doesn't have to be obnoxious to have his voice heard and I'd like to think that this is one of them.
"Too often we enjoy the comfort of opinion without the discomfort of thought." - John F. Kennedy on reality
"What if everything you see is more than what you see--the person next to you is a warrior and the space that appears empty is a secret door to another world? What if something appears that shouldn't? You either dismiss it, or you accept that there is much more to the world than you think. Perhaps it really is a doorway, and if you choose to go inside, you'll find many unexpected things." - Shigeru Miyamoto on secret doors to another world