Forums Submission Feedback

EmP's Thunder Force 2 review

Feedback on EmP's Thunder Force II review. 7 replies.

Marc Golding Staff Mar 15, 2011
Nicely done. AWESOME editing job by whoever your proofreader was, as well.
I don't have to prove I'm refined - that's what makes me refined!
Rob Hamilton Staff Mar 15, 2011
One of my fondest memories of TF 2 was one of those overhead stages that, I recall, was loaded with these webs or dots or something that you had to shoot to make a path through (contact was fatal, of course). However, because of your ship's speed and handling, you had to (as you mention) constantly turn around for a second before going back. Adding to the fun was how things seemed to respawn quickly in these levels, so the simple act of shooting through those barriers (of whatever they were) turned into this painful ordeal. Made worse by all the actual enemies buzzing around.
I'm not afraid to die because I am invincible
Viva la muerte, that's my goddamn principle
Marc Golding Staff Mar 15, 2011
I thought you were being sincere when I started reading...
I don't have to prove I'm refined - that's what makes me refined!
Rob Hamilton Staff Mar 15, 2011
Oh no. If there is a sincere favorite part, it'd be the final two REAL stages. It's been like 6-7 years since I've played the game and I still remember how awesome they were.
I'm not afraid to die because I am invincible
Viva la muerte, that's my goddamn principle
Joseph Shaffer Staff Mar 15, 2011
I love how this review sounds like this game is going to rock something fierce, then introduces the "but". Good read, EmP!
The only thing my milkshake brings to the yard is a subpoena.
Gary Hartley Staff Mar 17, 2011 edited
Reviewing this was hard going. I'd only ever played TF3 and 4 before which I enjoyed greatly, so 2 hit me like a mammoth kick in the teeth.

Thanks for reading, guys!
For us. For them. For you.
Brian Love Apr 8, 2011
Seeing such a low score was surprising, especially when Zero Wing scored higher. I feel that this score is overly critical for what was, for me, an early title for the Sega Genesis along with Forgotten Worlds and Altered Beast. Playing this was amazing, for its time, and it was rivaled in Nostalgia only by Herzog Zwei.

I have fond memories of beating this and it stands at the heights with Guardian Legend, Blaster Master, Grandia, Granada, R-Type, and Gradius, in my shooter library. These games were not all great, but the effect they made upon my being will be remembered fondly.

Just wanted to give an opinion, because the review is so well written that most would read it and instantly agree with all points, even if they had played the game in question.
Gary Hartley Staff Apr 8, 2011
The Zero Wing wasn’t written by me. I’ll happily admit I’ve not played that any further than the first stage, so I’ll refrain from commenting on the score.

Frankly, I would love do nothing more than delete the second half of the review and more than double the score, but those overhead sections make the bulk of the game and are truly awful. Perhaps I’m spoilt by playing the titles in reverse order and by seeing the positive evolution the series took once it dropped those clumsy stages, but it’s silly to ignore that this game is effectively sabotaged by them.

Of those shooters you named, I reviewed R-Type a few years back and gave it a 9 that I still stand firmly behind. I’m not a believer that games should be reviewed as if we were stuck in some weird time vortex where they’re still cutting edge day-one releases; the difference for me is that while R-Type still remains a great (if not frustrating) play, Thunder Force 2 is torture.

Still, I don’t blame you for not agreeing with the evaluation or the score -- people on this site’s staff are in disagreement with my review, too. Nor do I blame your reaction. Not long ago, I would have baulked at the thought of anyone low-reviewing one of my most nostalgically treasured shooter titles, Xenon 2. Then I replayed it and found that now matter how good it was back in the day, it’s an aged, obsolete title now that I wish I’d not revisited.

Props on the Herzog Zwei love, too. I still love that game. Thanks for reading my review of the game, and for taking the time to comment.
For us. For them. For you.

Log in to reply.