I judged a lot of these in my day!

Well, I don't know the overall rankings here, since I didn't save the other judges results. I'm not gonna list scores unless the people in question want them. But here's a list of people who submitted:

There's some confusion here. Did we have two of these comps in 2004?

Early 2004

ASchultz
Bloomer
Dark Vortex
Fastkilr
Genj
honestgamer
Janus
Masters
Neon Tiger X
Overdrive
purXtac
ragnarok757 (Denouement)
Sapharos
Sashanan
Sonic T Hedgehog
Space Megafighter X
Tachibana Ukyo
Vegita
Zap Rowsdower!!
Zigfried

Late 2004?

Asherdeus
Auto Rock
bbobb
bluberry
Denouement
espnking2002
Genjuro
Golden Vortex
GUTS
Janus
Leroux
Mariner
Midwinter
NT220
Overdrive
Pickhut
Sashanan
Sonic T Hedgehog
Space Megafighter X
Sportsman
Venter
Zigfried

2006

Amlabella
Auto Rock
Darketernal
Disco
DoI
Draqq
EmP
Fastkilr
Genj
Ghostyghost
Golden Vortex
Honestgamer
Janus
Lasthero
Leroux
Mclazyj
Overdrive
Pickhut
Pup
Redemption
Spaceworlder
Sportsman
Wolfqueen001

2007

BELISARIOS
BigCj34
Darketernal
Disco1960
DoI
EmP
Espiga
Felix
Genj
Johnny Cairo
Lasthero
Martin
Overdrive
Pickhut
Sho
Snow Dragon
Suskie
Will
Wolfqueen
Wootex

2008

Bluberry (scored a 0)
Darketernal
DoI
Drella
EmP
Lewis
Mrs. Venter*
MYass
Overdrive
Pickhut
Sho
Sportsman
Suskie
Timrod
True
Wolfqueen
Zipp

* Venter's horrible Sims 2 expansion review