SMT's design philosophy seems to be to have battles be 10% on-the-spot decision-making and 90% preparation. Sadly, the latter depends on getting destroyed repeatedly until you figure out what works, with copious amounts of menu navigation throughout. At least until you stumble upon an OP setup.
There's a thin line RPGs have to balance upon; avoiding gameplay that's just mashing the attack button, and avoiding gameplay that's grinding or trial-and-error. My favorite ones are games like F6 and Chrono Cross in which no grinding is required if you figure out a great setup, but you don't have to roll the dice or use spreadsheets like in SMT.
Fantastic review; does a great job of conveying problems difficult to put into words. Great job!
There's a thin line RPGs have to balance upon; avoiding gameplay that's just mashing the attack button, and avoiding gameplay that's grinding or trial-and-error. My favorite ones are games like F6 and Chrono Cross in which no grinding is required if you figure out a great setup, but you don't have to roll the dice or use spreadsheets like in SMT.
Fantastic review; does a great job of conveying problems difficult to put into words. Great job!
