In the Pit (Xbox 360) review
"Luvcraft's first-person action game In the Pit tells the tale of a murk-dwelling beast (you) who devours poor souls who fall into the Evil King's dark, dank pit. The game essentially plays like a chainsaw deathmatch except for one small difference: you can't see anything. Since you're a blind ravenous beast, this game is based around audio cues."
This is an Xbox Live Indie Games release. When playing indie games, I'm not looking for the production and sheen of a commercial release (although more power to anyone who pulls that off). I'm looking for ingenuity and talent. A game that showcases one, the other, or both is likely to receive a recommendation.
Luvcraft's first-person action game In the Pit tells the tale of a murk-dwelling beast (you) who devours poor souls who fall into the Evil King's dark, dank pit. The game essentially plays like a chainsaw deathmatch except for one small difference: you can't see anything. Since you're a blind ravenous beast, this game is based around audio cues. It's not a one-sided handicap — the pitch-black environment also hinders your armed prey, who occasionally stand still and hold their breath in an effort to listen to you slosh through the sewage. (Hint: stop moving when they do that, lest they fire an arrow through your gruesome heart.)
When I first heard the concept, my mind turned to Kenji Eno's Enemy Zero, in which the player hunts monsters by following a trail of high-frequency beeps. Players could actually see the surroundings in Enemy Zero; they just couldn't see the bloodthirsty aliens, because they were invisible (which, in retrospect, didn't make much sense). I suspect Eno realized that players rely on sight as a crutch, even if visual cues aren't governing the action.
With that in mind, it was pretty brave of In the Pit's designer to completely eliminate graphics. Some could construe that as laziness or an inability to draw, but based on the amount of effort and creativity put into the audio-centric concept, I would consider such assumptions hasty. In the Pit isn't a beep-following adventure like I expected — in this game, you'll hunt down each opponent by the sound of their breathing, heartbeats, or humorously-acted voices. It's surprisingly immersive, and surround sound or headphones are essential to enjoying the full experience. Although simple in design, I can't imagine it being done much better.
In the Pit features a dozen characters, at least half of which are humorously memorable. There's a big difference between people who think they're funny and people who really are funny; Luvcraft fortunately falls into the latter category with his witty writing and appropriately hammy (but oddly believable!) voice-acting. If someone told me that he starred in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, I would almost believe it. The plot's transition from "feed my beast", to the Quest for the Chalice of Gazonga, to the salvation of an oppressed populace is ridiculous but somehow works due to cleverly coherent writing. Each of the game's nine deathmatches build on earlier plot points, often in unexpected ways. It's like an episode of Seinfeld, where the joke seems kind of funny at first, but then keeps building and building until you realize you're trapped in an elaborate web of absurdity. By that point, practically every line is a joke of some sort.
Malicious king: "Succeed and I shall reward you with this large, un-cut diamond."
Blind archer: "That sounds like a square deal."
Should you perish during any encounter, you can continue right from where you died. Death can actually be amusing, since it often leads to extra quips. In addition to first-person ambling and eating, you can also dive beneath the water's surface, which is great for hiding from the wizard's "dark vision" spell or . . . other things that I won't spoil.
In the Pit may be simplistic, but it's an intriguing, creative game that showcases the designer's talent and makes me anticipate his future efforts. Audio-centric games are an essentially untapped well; kudos to Luvcraft for making that well appear worth tapping.
This game cost 240 points at the time of review.
Staff review by Zigfried (September 01, 2009)
Zigfried likes writing about whales and angry seamen, and often does so at the local pub.
If you enjoyed this In the Pit review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!