Google+   Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | DS | PS3 | PS4 | PSP | VITA | WII | WIIU | X360 | XB1 | All

Touch Detective (DS) artwork

Touch Detective (DS) review


"First off, this game is by Atlus, so of course itís going to offer something fresh. This game is so cutesy and fun, and itís available portably for the Nintendo DS. The DS seems like a perfect platform for more point-and-click titles and I was really excited when I was first reading about this one, despite its mixed reviews. I was definitely not disappointed because this game is a genuinely fun experience thatís easy-going, but still retains a level of difficulty with certain puzzles. "



First off, this game is by Atlus, so of course itís going to offer something fresh. This game is so cutesy and fun, and itís available portably for the Nintendo DS. The DS seems like a perfect platform for more point-and-click titles and I was really excited when I was first reading about this one, despite its mixed reviews. I was definitely not disappointed because this game is a genuinely fun experience thatís easy-going, but still retains a level of difficulty with certain puzzles.

The main character to this game is a young girl named Detective Mackenzie who has a sidekick blobby pet named Funghi and a butler named Cromwell. Her kooky friends, Penelope and Chloe, give her ďcasesĒ to solve. Each of the cases is titled, and even though there are only four cases in the game, theyíre fun and really unique.

This game is an item-puzzle type of point-and-click. Youíll be questioning people and trying to find the right items to solve predicaments that Mackenzie gets into. Some of the items combine to make new ones and itís interesting because since the game is on the DS, you have the ability to click on certain areas of objects to examine that particular spot. So, you have to really think about some items and look at them in the right way to figure out what their significance is.

Touch Detective gets its title from the fact that Mackenzie goes around touching things and she is declared a "touch detective" in the game. Well, that and the fact that the game is on the DS and utilizes the touchpad. The touchpad is used to navigate screens, menus, and touch things. When you find something new to touch, the game records it in a journal that you can read later with funny little icons and descriptions. Mackenzie records touching anything from floors, to railings, to curtains, and more. It makes the environments more interactive and gives you something extra to look for while youíre playing. Not only that, but the touchpad isnít even technically required for this game; the D-pad and buttons are also sufficient for moving around and investigating. It makes it quicker to go through conversations and also saves from having to risk scratching the pad (so you can let other people play it on your DS without being over-protective).

The cases in the game unlock new areas to explore, and even though the game is 2D, itís still detailed and there are lots of things to look at. Different places in the town that you explore include an ice skating rink, planetarium, and the circus (which turns out to be the flea circus!).

There are also new people to talk to in each case, which is actually one of the best parts of the game. The characters you meet in this game are really ďcharactersĒ. They say some of the goofiest things that the game actually made me laugh out loud. Also, while Mackenzie is talking to other characters, the top screen of the DS features what sheís really thinking about. Itís funny when Mackenzie is talking to someone strange and her thoughts mock them. Sometimes it seems like Mackenzieís the only normal person in the game, but then you remember she is a young girl detective who lives alone with a butler and a little brown blobby pet.

One thing thatís noticeable in this game is that while talking to people they are really strange-looking (aside from the kids). The lesser important adult characters look almost ghostly. The game features an abstract cell-shaded art-styling and the odd-looking adults only add an interesting dimension to the handheld graphical experience. It really makes it seem as though the adults are living in this world that is actually Mackenzieís (and the other young charactersí) world, not theirs. Not only are the adults strangely ghost-like, but some of the other characters are animals. Thereís a walrus, a bird, and other weird ďpeopleĒ in the game.

The music in this game is also great. Even though the game is on the DS, the music is still fun and you can even listen to the tunes while youíre not working on a case. Simply turn on the radio in Mackenzieís room and all the songs thus far are available to jam out to. A couple of the songs are really good, a couple of them are slightly repetitive though depending on how long you spend wandering unsuccessfully for clues. None of the characters actually have voices, though; the dialogue is text-based. However, they do have fun theme songs!

Which brings me to my next point; this game has difficulty to it. Even though itís really fun, cutesy, and kid-looking, the game still features involved-ness enjoyable to an older player. A couple of times, I had no clue what to do next. The game keeps you guessing what to look for or who to talk to next. Itís not too hard, but itís not extremely easy either. It has a pleasant difficulty level, thatís for sure. Then, there are also additional mini-cases where you help people around town after the main cases. This helps to make an otherwise seemingly short game last longer.

The main point is that this game is fun! Itís really, genuinely, addictively fun! If you pick up this game, youíll be laughing at the characters while bopping to the fun music and searching for clues with your blobby sidekick. Not only that, but you also get to touch random things and mock other people in your thoughts! What more could a point-and-clicker ask for? This game is definitely win-win.

Rating: 8/10

jill's avatar
Community review by jill (May 19, 2009)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by jill
Silent Hill: Homecoming (Xbox 360) artwork
Silent Hill: Homecoming (Xbox 360)

Another new developer takes a shot at making a Silent Hill title, Double Helix. Do they bring in the support of hardcore fans of the series, or do they disappoint? Well, I wouldn't exactly call myself a "hardcore fan" of the series, but I am a pretty big fan of it. I think that this game is one of the more playable gam...
Resident Evil 4 (GameCube) artwork
Resident Evil 4 (GameCube)

Ok, can I just say one thing? Wow. Just... Wow. This game is a lot better than I thought it was going to be, to be completely honest. I mean, there were so many people talking about how this game was going to be so different from the other ones, that it would completely change the series. Well, I don't think it complet...
Silent Hill 4: The Room (PlayStation 2) artwork
Silent Hill 4: The Room (PlayStation 2)

Another Silent Hill game and I find myself reviewing it. It is actually hard to believe that there is a 4th addition to the series. I can remember when the first one came out and playing it for the first time. And now, years later, here is Silent Hill 4.

Feedback

If you enjoyed this Touch Detective review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
zippdementia posted May 20, 2009:

Usually I like reading reviews when the two reviewers have given such drastically different scores, because comparing the two can usually lead one on to the path of truth. However, in this case, it's tough. It's like you got sent a different version of the game from woodhouse. He complains about Mackenzie's lack of character and thoughts. You praise her thoughts on the other characters. Woodhouse complains about the game not being comical, you rave about how funny it is. Woodhouse says there's no logic to the puzzles, you call the game pleasantly difficult.

So it comes down to who's review is the more compelling and the most believable.

It's a difficult decision. You both do a good job of infusing your reviews with emotion, even if they are emotions on polar ends of the spectrum. Ultimately, the thing I think you could've done better was to explain some of your adjectives. It's all well and good to say characters are funny, but it's well and BETTER to actually give an example of one of their jokes and let the reader decide for themselves.

Woodhouse has given plenty of reasons and examples as to why this game could be harsh on the soul. Your blatant enthusiasm makes me question woodhouse, frankly, and I give you props for that. But ultimately, he lays more evidence on the table.

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

Info | Help | Privacy Policy | Contact | Advertise | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2014 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Touch Detective is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Touch Detective, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors.