Patreon button  Steam curated reviews  Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | AND | IOS | PC | PS4 | NS | VITA | WIIU | XB1 | All

Stardew Valley (PC) artwork

Stardew Valley (PC) review


"In times of turmoil, turning up the soil of the past can be a great comfort."


Who wakes up to find their wallet loaded with coin from the previous nightís shipment of produce? Who spends twenty eight days, of which each of the four seasons consist, in anticipation of the next day? Who hands gifts to total strangers in the hopes of befriending or even marrying them? In Stardew Valley, you do.

Your Grandfather is bedridden, and though why is not clear, he gifts you with a letter you are to open when you tire of the grind of modern living. A few stylized screens later and you are standing in front of his old farmhouse in the titular valley, aghast at the monumental challenge. Youíre given a few consoling words, and left to your own devices.

You are now master of several acres of quite wild land, and given no exact quota to meet. In Stardew Valley there are helpful NPCs, a handful of events and quests, but everything is optional. You are never castigated for not partaking of these offerings. You are encouraged to do things, often as a very gentle tutorial to help you survive so that you may follow your interests.

Stardew proudly wears its influences on its sleeve, its head, its tush ... you get the idea. This is one of its greatest strengths, as the aesthetic of the SNES edition of Harvest Moon is its first seedling. The world is presented in 1990s style 8-bit pixel art, with low animation counts and hardware scaling tricks to bring the impact home. For instance, your tools are not animated, but rotated with the addition of motion-suggesting sprites. Itís snappy and quite effective at communicating the impact of most of your implements.

Yet itís abundantly clear that other games contributed their influence to Stardewís winning personality. What I am going to do is talk paths and the influences I recognize in each of them. Letís start with the farming. But wait, I hear you say, what do you mean by ďpathsĒ?

ConcernedApe has stressed that there is no one way to win, even though some pursuits are more lucrative than others. Winning, I gather, means revitalizing the farm and rediscovering the joy of living, over a three year period. Each month, or season, has twenty eight days ... which means you have ... (grabs calculator) ... 336 days until his return.

What? Donít ask me, thatís what the note said on his shrine. You see, before we get on to paths, thatís the sidewinder you arenít expecting from Stardew Valley. If youíre interested in it, stop reading this review and go buy it right now. Donít wait for a sale, donít wait for me to tell you what a delight it is. Go. Iíll be here if you want to return. Have fun!

...

Still here? Paths it is. You see, while Farming is going to pay your way three seasons out of four, it has many facets and even deeper interactions that will encourage you to explore all possibilities. It can be argued that you canít avoid them if you want to unlock portions of Stardew Valleyís map, and more. Since youíre going to be busy anyway, thatís not a bad thing, as all aspects of the title radiate charm.

Thatís right. Radiate. There is an unexpected supernatural element to the game that can augment your earnings and interactions with the environment. No spoilers, as really, Iím just halfway through the fall in my longest running map. Fair is fair.

Just look at all that digression. Goodness. Letís take some and look at the nostalgic design elements we were going to discuss.

Mining has combat. Oh yes, and it positively oozes Secret of Mana/Evermore/Seiken Densetsu III all over. You have a selection of weapons to choose from with unique properties, such as swing arc, impact and precision. You may block, with the sword, at least, and you know what? You can cut grass.

On my first playthrough of Secret of Mana I hunted grass nearly as much as the monsters because of this brand new interaction Ė think 1995, folks. Combat in Stardew however, is nowhere near as taxing, at first. As the difficulty curves, so will your access to better gear to meet the enemies in the deep. Youíll also be picking up essential ores for crafting as well. SOE was known for the necessity of items for magic, though Stardewís approach is naturally more broad.

What is fishing like? Apparently not much; you may immediately recognize the line casting system from Minecraft, Terraria and others, but its reeling mini game will keep you on your toes with its physics oriented take on something sincerely physical. Itís a great analog, and you might curse a little when the big one gets away because of your impatience and imprecision.

Relationships. A staple of farming life simulators is the ability to court a guy or gal and eventually propose and marry them. Like any pursuit, you must be persistent, as all of the characters have daily habits and patterns to learn. They also have likes and dislikes as gifts, and when they see you root through someoneís trash. You can marry whomever you choose regardless of gender, provided theyíre (Single), and even divorce them if you want to. Apparently itís horrible, though Iíve no idea, personally.

Star Valley has a way of feeling deeply personal. Graphically it is lush, animated with enough subtly to evoke the suspension of disbelief, but not crowded with color or details. The music is brimming with personality, employing a banjo without hesitation or misstep. That is to say, ConcernedApe knows when enough is enough, and layers other instruments in for a truly rustic feel. Summer sounds like a hot, risky season of delicate balance, whereas youíll hear sustained synth pads during Fall that may make you stop to admire the falling leaves.

Iíd like to say that Stardew Valley will run on any hardware, and that is nearly true, but in spite of low system requirements, I experienced frame drops on more than able hardware. This did not impede my progress and is easily patchable, I suspect. As of this writing the developer has been active in updates, as Stardew has hit the mass market with its lovable charm.

Whatís Fun
Everything. Farming offers choices aplenty; animals, battery manufacture, fruit, vegetables, foraging and even foresting. Character interactions are not as deep as a visual novel, but the environment tells a story deeper than the dialogue.

Whatís Not
Letís face it, this is a farming simulator. Stardew Valley has a three year story arc and maps with unique environments, you are performing virtual chores, and they will remain as interesting as they are new to you.

Recommendation
Stardew Valley is finding a new, in fact, older, audience of players who grew up on this experience and wanted some nostalgia. What they got was hours and hours of charm and personality with expert presentation, a heartfelt soundtrack and the freedom to choose. Buy it, and pay full price Ė you wonít regret it.

5/5

hastypixels's avatar
Community review by hastypixels (November 22, 2016)

Is a fan of technology, but not of software implementations. Usually haunting a keyboard surrounded by LCD screens. When he's not making a living building stuff out of wood, that is.

More Reviews by hastypixels [+]
Fez (PC) artwork
Fez (PC)

Fez is a charmer of masterful execution that invites you to explore and check your stress at the door.
Secret of Mana (SNES) artwork
Secret of Mana (SNES)

About as quirky as it gets without being Indie.
Final Fantasy IX (PC) artwork
Final Fantasy IX (PC)

A familiar tale of romanticism and the destructive cycle of war. And then thereís Vivi.

Feedback

If you enjoyed this Stardew Valley review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
Linkamoto posted December 31, 2016:

Well done, hasty. I had to read at least one review of this game, as I personally have been vacillating about whether to purchase it or not. In reading your (well-written) review, I am now determined to play the game.

However...I've read there are performance issues PARTICULARLY on the console versions. I had not read about any PC issues until your review. In any event, I do not game on PC at all, so I'm really concerned about spending any money at all on a terribly performing game. Do you have any comment on the console side of things?

Great review here. Loved your mastery of the language--your ability to write an enthralling review of a game that, while amazing to older Harvest Moon-type players, is steeped in mundanity. Hope to read more from you.
board icon
hastypixels posted January 01, 2017:

I haven't heard any complaints about performance on console, but apparently using a controller complicates mini-games like fishing. Tools like the slingshot are avoided on principle, being really silly to target on principle.

The PC version has controller support, and I found targeting with tools awkward. The left analog stick controls the on screen cursor, which you need to use to pick up items, and that takes getting used to. I don't know if the console version has keyboard/mouse support, though most do at the OS level, which means it's possible.

Thank you for your feedback. Goal achieved. :) Stardew Valley has possibly the most positive atmosphere in the entire gaming industry. I'd recommend it to anyone.

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

Policies/Ethics | Contact | Advertise | Sponsor Guide | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2017 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Stardew Valley is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Stardew Valley, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.