Despite this, the final episode still wastes some time trying to bond me with a cast who, thanks to the brevity with which they’ve been established, I find myself really struggling to care about. An early central dispute is trying to decide if you should stick around and face an upcoming danger, or just make a break for it. The game wants you to then convince members of your rapidly-thinning group to go along with whatever choice you subscribe to. That fact that Paige wanted to leave while everyone else started digging in was supposed to be a moment of panic. In reality, I previously held exactly one conversation with the girl and that short exchange had left so little an impression on me that I had completely forgotten her name.

That’s the problem with the entire cast. Aside from the leading lady, no one’s been established beyond a bullet point of character traits highlighted in neon to try and guide how you feel about them. Randall’s an over-the-top arsehat -- he says mean things to the people who destroyed his home and killed his friends, but does he have to be such a jerk about it? To that end, the big decision to make in Episode 2 was to keep him alive as a bargaining chip, or to beat him to death with a wrench. Telltale has made me want to beat people to death with a wrench before. They’ve not done so here.
And there’s the big problem. The Walking Dead: Michonne asks me to wage war against a group I don’t hate to serve as protector to a group I don’t care about. Michonne side steps this mainly because she’s preexisting and established, but this just creates further issues. What if you don’t hold the knowledge the game assumes you do? Just as bad, what if you do? More than ever before, the final chapter makes it clear that there's a true path you're supposed to take on your way through the choices presented. Deviating from this means making decisions wildly out of Michonne’s character, making the choices you are presented with seem more shallow than ever. I mean, we’ve all played Telltale stuff before and we know there’s never going to be any hugely relevant alterations to the story based on the snap decisions you have to make. The draw has always been in making these on the fly, based on who you’ve decided you want your protagonist to be. But previous protagonists Lee and Clementine didn’t have years of back story living in our heads, telling us that Unthinkable Option 2 is just plain wrong.

This narrative flaw sadly bleeds into the second half of What We Deserve, where the game stops pretending the other survivors matter and starts exploring the grief and guilt leaking out of Michonne’s malfunctioning mind. The fluttering images of her dead children has been ever-present throughout her mini adventure, always getting worse as the stress and danger ramps up or dies too far down. It’s actually kind of brilliant, purposefully muddying what’s real and what’s imagined. The rapid-fire cuts and changes do more than just stick two creepy kids somewhere in the background, like a pair of preadolescent Slendermen with braids. They force you down the rabbit hole along with Michonne, make you question whether the actions you take are affecting the world and the people around her, or remain a vivid personification of her war against insanity.
It’s always been the case with this series; the sporadic high points have always come when Telltale found new ways to showcase Michonne’s inability to cope with her loss. While What We Deserve and the episodes that came before it aren’t about to serve her redemption, they do offer small pinpricks of hope. And it’s the right way to go. When the shit finally hits the fan, Michonne effortlessly shows why zombies aren’t a particularly big threat. Shuffling the deck, then, to treat physical threats as a curiosity while threatening to bury her in a mental collapse was easily the smartest thing this game has done.






