Patreon button  Steam curated reviews  Discord button  Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | PC | PS4 | PS5 | SWITCH | VITA | XB1 | XSX | All

MLB 11: The Show (PlayStation 3) artwork

MLB 11: The Show (PlayStation 3) review

"MLB 11: The Show spent the off-season focusing on core mechanics and the latest entry delivers substantially."

One of the first things I always hear people say when they talk about Sony's baseball series is that it's hard. There is no game that more accurately portrays what it is like to play baseball, and baseball is apparently a difficult sport to play. MLB: The Show has achieved this reputation of difficult-but-accurate simulation as the series has progressed, and last year's edition was unrivaled in terms of presentation and authenticity. MLB 11: The Show spent the off-season focusing on core mechanics and the latest entry delivers substantially.

MLB 11 is defined by the Road to the Show mode, where users can create their own player and work them from minor league substitute to Hall of Famer. In last year's edition I made the mistake of thinking I was good enough at the game to be a second baseman, so this year I choose to create a starting pitcher. This gave me a lot of time to get acclimated with MLB 11's new pitching mechanics. The classic on-screen meter requiring button presses at specific times in order to deliver a pitch has been reworked into a fully analog option. The system works very similarly, requiring the player to pull back on the analog stick and then forward once a certain point is hit, but it also brings timing into play. How quickly or slowly you press the analog stick up affects how the ball moves across the plate.

The system works very well and as I progressed through the game's Road to the Show mode, I started to see the improvements I had made to my player through the training options. I really got into each game and was probably more engaged during my starts than I was when watching a real baseball game. MLB 11 does an absolutely amazing job replicating not just the look of baseball, but also the feel of the game. Sure, you get accurately modeled players and ballpark-specific broadcast angles and all of that, but the game goes further and delivers the tension of baseball. There's an added pressure to each pitch when you're late in the game and clinging onto a tight lead. I was invested in my player player, working toward goals, and making my way to the major league. I also cursed a number of times after being pulled from a game and finding out I got the loss despite stellar performances.

The new pitching mechanics have been complimented by analog hitting controls. Players once again pull back on the analog stick to stride and then press forward to swing the bat through the strike zone. This gives players total control over the bat, allowing players to hold up when they shouldn't have swung, pepper shots across the field, and bunt without having to press a button. Though hitting a ball into play is still tough, I found that I felt like I was actually progressing and improving as I played further and started to see results. In last years' edition, I felt like I played game after game and couldn't put anything together. In this version, I felt like I could at least maintain a minor league batting average.

All around, the Road to the Show feels like it does a better job of accurately gauging your performance than last year's rather arcane and mysterious system did. Training points are awarded after every single play, so you receive constant feedback on your performance after every pitch, strikeout, or fielded grounder. Do something well and you're instantly rewarded. The game is even smart enough to reward you if you push the pitcher’s pitch count up but fail to get a hit. Failure is discouraged through the subtraction of training points. It's a simple system that helps players to instantly gauge how well they're doing without having to navigate menus outside of the game. Getting a huge chunk of training points after a three-pitch strikeout is almost as satisfying as unlocking a trophy.

MLB 11 comes with a laundry list of other new features. The new co-op mode, which allows for up to four players to face off locally or online, is fun for players who are invested in the game. It's not particularly friendly to novices and they may grow bored quickly. There's a new dynamic weather system that actually makes you appreciate the setting sun over some field in Arkansas during your AA days. And, in one of the coolest moves I've ever seen a developer take, there's even a difficultly setting specifically geared toward making the game more accessible to individuals with disabilities.

But not everything is bright and sunny. MLB 11 is a big game, the Gran Turismo of baseball. With that comes long, long, (long!) loading and saving times. I know this is a detailed game, but spending more time loading and saving than you spent playing after being called in to face one batter is aggravating. And while the commentary is serviceable, I had issues with it stuttering at times and it doesn't take long for the commentating to become repetitive, even with Eric Karros joining as third commentator. Though the new hitting and pitching interface is easy to understand and certainly an improvement over previous year's models, I still think the game could benefit with some stronger training sessions, perhaps using interactive tutorials to help teach players how to see the ball, when to swing, etc., outside of games.

MLB 11 does an excellent job once again at delivering what this franchise is all about. The pitching/hitting interface is excellent and teaches players how to throw and hit in an intuitive and natural manner. MLB 11's presentation is unrivaled, and everything down to the stadium-specific Jumbotrons are presented with beautiful accuracy. There are enough changes with this year’s edition to justify a purchase, and the new mechanics make it a strong suggestion it to fans who were put off by last year's unforgiving learning curve. Major work was done in making this game not only more authentic but more accessible, and on both fronts the developers succeeded. MLB 11 stands as one of Sony's strongest exclusives.


asherdeus's avatar
Featured community review by asherdeus (April 05, 2011)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by asherdeus [+]
GoldenEye 007: Reloaded (Xbox 360) artwork
GoldenEye 007: Reloaded (Xbox 360)

The game is in many ways a perfect example of Activision's consistent mishandling of the Bond license. It's certainly gotten a little more polish than your average licensed Activision release, but it’s still not worth your time.
Deus Ex: Human Revolution (PC) artwork
Deus Ex: Human Revolution (PC)

Eidos Montreal deftly updated the game to give it more modern sensibilities while retaining the core of what captivated us with the original. I'd even go as far as arguing that this is the very best entry in the series and closest to the original vision of what the game could be, though some may disagree.
Bodycount (PlayStation 3) artwork
Bodycount (PlayStation 3)

Somewhere along the way, the vision for this game was lost and what remains is a jumbled, unsatisfying mess. There are good ideas here - the controls work very well and the core ideas the game calls on have potential. It's just very poorly conceived. Nothing really meshes together and I got the feeling that it was just...


If you enjoyed this MLB 11: The Show review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
fleinn posted April 06, 2011:

More people than me who are tired of the murder-simulations lately..? :)

Good review. The entire authentic vs. accessible is nicely described, and avoids all kinds of strange tropes about gamer demographics and preferences for explanations.

Not sure I'm completely sold on baseball, though.. I tried the demo, and hit the batter in the head at least ten times. And the commentators were just making fun of me the whole time. Then suddenly everyone ran around the field for no reason, and the commentators started to laugh again. Stupid game. :p
board icon
asherdeus posted April 06, 2011:

Seriously! This was such a refreshing break from shooters. I feel like every game I play lately I'm some hulking, oversized super soldier. Not that I don't love that, of course, but going from Bulletstorm to Killzone to Homefront to Crysis ... uhg. I couldn't even make a dent in most of them and some of them I ended up not even getting past the main menu on (Homefront).
board icon
honestgamer posted April 06, 2011:

A steady diet of games within any one genre is good for no one, but it does seem that more and more people lately are finding themselves tiring of the FPS. That's not good for the genre but it could be good for the industry.

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

User Help | Contact | Ethics | Sponsor Guide | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2021 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. MLB 11: The Show is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to MLB 11: The Show, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.