Patreon button  Steam curated reviews  Discord button  Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | PC | PS4 | PS5 | SWITCH | VITA | XB1 | XSX | All

The Silver Lining: Episode 1 - What is Decreed Must Be (PC) artwork

The Silver Lining: Episode 1 - What is Decreed Must Be (PC) review

"The Silver Lining: What Is Decreed Must Be is aimed squarely at hardcore King's Quest lovers who want to see the series given a proper send-off. As a loving fan service, there's quite a bit to like, but as a game, it stumbles rather badly."

King's Quest. It stands as one of the most influential video games of all time, a genre-defining release that put Sierra Online on the path to becoming the dominant game company of its era and made its creator, Roberta Williams, a legend in the industry. Based on that famous series of adventures, The Silver Lining (and, specifically, its first chapter, What Is Decreed Must Be) is very much a love-letter to Williams and her creation: heartfelt, sincere and, like many declarations of undying romance, very, very awkward.

That The Silver Lining is a fan-made game is clearly reflected in the rough edges and lack of polish that simply wouldn't pass muster in a studio release. It's more technologically advanced than any of the original King's Quest games (which should be no surprise, given that the series ended in 1998) but actually comes off feeling rather more primitive. Visually, the game is very sparse and while the soundtrack is impressive, the voice acting is noticeably uneven: Azure, King of the Winged Ones, appears to be having a blast chewing the virtual scenery but the voice of Oberon sounds more like a first reading of the script recorded through a dollar-store microphone.

The game is technically solid but, like everything else in the game, a little rough-hewn. It runs flawlessly but the loading times between screens seem a bit lengthy given their relative dearth of content and occasional bits of syntactical wonkiness pop up here and there in the writing. Navigating corners can be problematic; King Graham, the central character, has an annoying habit of getting hung up if he's not carefully maneuvered around them at a safe distance, although I suppose that for true fans of old-time adventures that might actually be part of the charm.

The Silver Lining certainly plays like a King's Quest game, which is to say it plays like a standard point-and-click adventure. The right mouse button cycles the cursor through all the standard adventure commands, like move, examine, get and so forth, while the left button activates the selected function. The same commands are available from a drop-down menu, as is a fairly standard inventory screen that offers easy access to all your stored items for examination or use. Camera controls are entirely automatic and although odd angles can occasionally make movement a bit trickier than it should be, the non-action nature of the game means that such shortcomings generally don't cause any serious problems.

What is a problem, however, is the lack of actual gameplay. What Is Decreed Must Be is less a game than a cutscene that requires you to click every now and then in order to progress it. The adventure opens with a slow, overlong video of the wedding between Rosella and Edgar on the Green Isles; once that goes awry, players in the guise of King Graham will wander around the castle a bit, speak to a few guards, walk to a deserted town and then, with nothing else to do, charter a boat to travel among the Green Isles in search of the Oracle of the Isle of the Sacred Mountain. Once the boat ride begins, meaningful interactivity ends; Graham will meet with the King and Queen of the Winged Ones and, when that's wrapped up, take his boat to a different island for an equally expositional encounter with the Druids, but for all intents and purposes the "game" is out of the player's hands.

To be fair, this is only the first of five planned chapters. A certain amount of setup is to be expected, yet very little useful "pre-game action" actually takes place. What Is Decreed Must Be assumes that players are already so familiar with the King's Quest setting that there's no need to explain what's going on or why players should care. Consider Graham himself: before leaving the castle, he changes from his Kingly garb into the classic red tunic and blue cap, remarking in an aside that people always mistake him for a commoner when he's wearing his adventuring clothes.

So why, you might wonder, does he insist on wearing them? Why not just go out dressed as the King? Fans will surely appreciate the moment, but players who aren't familiar with the series will probably just find it confusing. Other questions likewise go unanswered. Why is the castle guarded by talking dogs? Why are the Winged Ones such jerks? Why won't those two weirdos come out of the rain? And who are all these strange wedding guests, anyway? I was a pretty solid King's Quest fan back in the day but I quit after KQ4 and that was 1988, kids. Unless you're a serious aficionado, be prepared to make the occasional trip to Google if you want to stay fully up to speed on what's happening.

What Is Decreed Must Be is also liberally salted with cutesy remarks and asides that break the fourth wall. When examining a bonsai tree, for instance, the narrator says they come from Japan and then tries to explain it to Graham as the place that makes all of the "great video games and anime." Other comments include remarks about containers being empty due to some "grand, cosmic game design" and even a "shameless plug" for the narrator's own personal website. How well this works is largely a matter of personal taste and, like everything else, it may appeal to fans, but I found it distracting and counter-immersive.

The bottom line is that The Silver Lining: What Is Decreed Must Be is aimed squarely at hardcore King's Quest lovers who want to see the series given a proper send-off. As a loving fan service, there's quite a bit here to like. References to past games abound and seeing Graham don the old red-and-blue and hit the trail once more has an undeniably romantic appeal. But on its own merits as a game, it stumbles rather badly. There's little to see and less to do. To be perfectly frank, I expected a more polished experience from a game that spent a decade in development. I'm hopeful that future chapters will have more to offer, and since it's free there's no reason not to give this one a go if you're curious. But players expecting a rebirth of the great King's Quest series will probably be disappointed. As a paean to Roberta Williams it's admirable, but as a game it just doesn't live up to its billing.

Malygris's avatar
Freelance review by Andy Chalk (July 11, 2010)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by Andy Chalk [+]
Gas Guzzlers Combat Carnage (PC) artwork
Gas Guzzlers Combat Carnage (PC)

Gas Guzzlers: Combat Carnage is a really, really good game, and you're missing out on it.
Dear Esther (PC) artwork
Dear Esther (PC)

Dear Esther is barely a videogame by any conventional sense of the term and approaching it like one will lead to nothing but frustration. But if you're lucky, it clicks, not as a game but as a powerful and moving emotional experience.
Hard Reset (PC) artwork
Hard Reset (PC)

Hard Reset isn't quite able to live up to the high standards of mayhem set by Serious Sam and Painkiller, but it gets enough right to be a lot of wrist-snapping fun.


If you enjoyed this The Silver Lining: Episode 1 - What is Decreed Must Be review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
zippdementia posted July 11, 2010:

I commented on this already in the production room, so you know I think it's a great review, and I think your changes have helped it read smoother.

I still have a problem with this line:

The game is technically solid but, like everything else in the game, a little rough-hewn.

Same comment as before... it's like saying "my room is technically large, but like everything else in the room, a little dirty." I don't know if you see the problem with redundancy there, but it does exist. It would be more passable if it read "the game is technically solid, but like everything in it, a little rough hewn" or even better as simply "the game is techinically solid but a little rough-hewn."
board icon
Suskie posted July 12, 2010:

Wait... Your name is Andy Chalk? Are you from the Escapist?
board icon
Malygris posted July 12, 2010:

Yup, it is an ugly line. I did actually look at it last night after your original suggestion and I thought it seemed fine, but it rides a whole lot rougher with fresh eyes this AM.

Unfortunately, I'd like to change it but I can't. :)

It's too bad about the game. Maybe the remaining chapters will step it up, but strictly from an academic point of view (I have a huge amount of respect for the KQ games, if no particular love) it was a letdown. Fan project or not, with this much time to ferment the game should've been a lot more polished. I could have forgiven the lack of interactivity as part of the necessary setup procedure if there had been enough meat on the bone to really involve me, but it just wasn't there.
board icon
Malygris posted July 12, 2010:

Yes, one and the same. But they don't generally let me do reviews. ;)

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

User Help | Contact | Ethics | Sponsor Guide | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2021 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. The Silver Lining: Episode 1 - What is Decreed Must Be is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to The Silver Lining: Episode 1 - What is Decreed Must Be, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.