Patreon button  Steam curated reviews  Discord button  Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | PC | PS4 | PS5 | SWITCH | VITA | XB1 | XSX | All

Black (Xbox) artwork

Black (Xbox) review

"Letís talk about realism for a minute. The video game industry is ďsupposedĒ to be moving towards realistic everything. Realistic gameplay thatís so technical it isnít fun (Ghost Recon anyone?). Audio realism thatís so accurate youíll swear youíre actually on the battlefield. Photo-realism with girls and cars that look ďbetterĒ than the real thing (check out Gran Turismo). Weíre told that we shouldn't want games that look like cartoons anymore, and that we should want super-detaile..."

Letís talk about realism for a minute. The video game industry is ďsupposedĒ to be moving towards realistic everything. Realistic gameplay thatís so technical it isnít fun (Ghost Recon anyone?). Audio realism thatís so accurate youíll swear youíre actually on the battlefield. Photo-realism with girls and cars that look ďbetterĒ than the real thing (check out Gran Turismo). Weíre told that we shouldn't want games that look like cartoons anymore, and that we should want super-detailed, hyper-realistic looking environments and guns and character models that look just like the real whatever-they-ares. In this respect, Black succeeds completely. The guns look real enough to touch. The enemies that you battle against look superb. The environments have fantastic draw distances and excellent texturing. All of these fantastic features run at a solid framerate. In terms of audio, the game again delivers an incredibly realistic experience. As you sit in front of your television, youíll swear that you can really hear bullets whizzing by your head and man, that score really pulls you into the game.

While Black may have an outstanding presentation, notice that I never once mentioned "realistic gameplay." This is because Black is clearly made by people who do not have a proper understanding of the first-person shooter genre. For starters, you canít jump in Black. Now, the game is designed so that you donít really need to jump, Iíll admit that, but the exclusion of a jump ability hurts the feel of the game. Itís incredibly annoying and frustrating when you walk off of a ledge and canít turn around and go back to where you just were. The exclusion of a jump ability makes it hard to strategically plan the use of health packs because half of the time you canít get to health packs that you've left behind for later use. Since you canít jump, you canít launch surprise attacks on enemies on lower-levels. The only thing you can do is snipe them from above, which isn't nearly as thrilling as launching a grenade down into a crowd of terrorists, waiting for it to blow, and then hopping down upon them with guns-blazing.

Black is also obnoxiously linear. There is no guess work when planning on where you need to go next, which takes a lot of fun out of being an elite counter-terrorist trying to track down a very notorious terrorist who is ďalways one step ahead of the authorities.Ē Generally I donít mind linear gamers (F.E.A.R. was incredibly linear and incredibly sweet), but again, the inexperience of the developers shows. Please, game developers, do a better job of creating an environment than just corralling me into an area with a shin-high ledge that any normal human being could walk over but for some reason our oh-so-elite counter-terrorist character canít handle.

Even worse, you canít fall off roofs or into holes in floors unless the game lets you. In one particular sequence in the ďlaterĒ portions of the game (later in quotes because the game is a measly five hours long), you have to cross a partially destroyed bridge. This scene could have been incredibly intense and easily could have topped the very entertaining bridge sequence in Half-Life 2, but since thereís no risk of falling into any of the holes in the partially destroyed bridge as you fight in vicious gun-battles, the whole thing feels fake and plastic. Without having to be aware of the environment around you, do you really think youíre going to appreciate how awesome they look?

But Black is all about GUN BATTLES!

Yeah, it really is, because thereís nothing else for the game to be about. I have to say; one thing that I did like about the gameplay in Black is that it isnít just a mindless run-and-gun shooter. You actually need to strategize most situations (even if strategy just boils down to memorizing patterns and timing when to pop out from behind cover and shoot). It makes most battles more interesting and some battles even memorable. But the battles would be a lot more enjoyable (and my review a lot more favorable too) if the battles werenít so unbalanced. For starters, on the last level, where youíre supposed to be finally confronting the evil terrorist mastermind, you go in alone. Yeah, a lot of video games make you go it alone against the final boss. But Black breaths "realism" remember. When we finally figure out Where in the World Is Osama Bin Laden?, weíre probably going to send in 50,000 soldiers to make sure we get him. The guy youíre tracking down is as notorious as Bin Laden is. So why, in a game trying to be so realistic, would they send me in all alone? Yes, this does increase the challenge for the gamer, but it's very unrealistic considering that you do have backup for at least half the game.

And during gun battles, why does it take nearly a full clip of ammunition to take down your enemies? Yes, I understand that theyíre wearing armor, and Iíll admit that I donít understand body armor entirely, but Iím reasonably positive that 30 well-placed shots no matter what is strapped to their chest. So why does it sometimes require 60 bullets to take them down? Now, before you tell me that I should just aim for their heads, let me point out that the battles get incredibly intense because this game uses respawning enemies to keep the action tight while youíre attempting to complete your objectives. When enemies are continuously respawned during several sequences in the game, you donít always have time to aim for their heads (and for the record, 27% of my kills did come from headshots). These respawning enemies become very problematic because health packs are incredibly limited and combined with the fact that they take a ton of damage to go down, you spend a lot of time fighting them.

While Iím on that subject, let me go into depth about the enemies. They suck, too. The enemy roster includes: a guy with the machine gun, a guy with the shotgun, a guy with the rocket launcher, and a guy with the shield. No one else, just those four foes (and theyíre all men too). You have to kill them all in the same fashion for the entire length of the game. For the shield guys, you need to throw a grenade behind them, because for some reason, peppering them with three or four clips of high-velocity rounds from a machine gun or sixteen blasts from a shotgun into their shield never causes damage to the shield or the shield holder to drop said shield. For the shotgun guys, you need to shoot them until they fall on their backs, and then you need to shoot them as soon as they stand up again. The rocket launcher guys always shoot one rocket in the wrong direction so you can see where they are, and when you kill them, they explode and fall off whatever ledge they were on.

This makes for a very boring game.

Black is a regression for first-person shooters. The graphics and sound might be a great leap forward, but the rest of the game fails to meet any of the current criteria for a good first-person shooter. Weíve just played through F.E.A.R. , Half-Life 2, FarCry, Halo 2, Quake 4, and Call of Duty 2. Itís been a great couple of years for first-person shooters. I really donít want to play a game that feels like it's a ten years old relic from the past and thatís what the gameplay in Black feels like. When youíre playing Black, it feels like youíre being led by the hand and someone is pointing at all the things you should like and telling you to like them. Thatís not what we want. If this sounds like a fun experience, I still suggest avoiding picking this game up because there are no multiplayer options and the game is only five hours long with very little reason to play through it again. Black is a disappointing game that you should definitely avoid.

asherdeus's avatar
Community review by asherdeus (May 10, 2006)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by asherdeus [+]
GoldenEye 007: Reloaded (Xbox 360) artwork
GoldenEye 007: Reloaded (Xbox 360)

The game is in many ways a perfect example of Activision's consistent mishandling of the Bond license. It's certainly gotten a little more polish than your average licensed Activision release, but itís still not worth your time.
Deus Ex: Human Revolution (PC) artwork
Deus Ex: Human Revolution (PC)

Eidos Montreal deftly updated the game to give it more modern sensibilities while retaining the core of what captivated us with the original. I'd even go as far as arguing that this is the very best entry in the series and closest to the original vision of what the game could be, though some may disagree.
Bodycount (PlayStation 3) artwork
Bodycount (PlayStation 3)

Somewhere along the way, the vision for this game was lost and what remains is a jumbled, unsatisfying mess. There are good ideas here - the controls work very well and the core ideas the game calls on have potential. It's just very poorly conceived. Nothing really meshes together and I got the feeling that it was just...


If you enjoyed this Black review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

User Help | Contact | Ethics | Sponsor Guide | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998 - 2024 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Black is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Black, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.