Critical Depth (PlayStation) review "Critical Depth is a very enjoyable action game. It takes vehicular combat to a whole new level, literally. Many people may just find this as another Twisted Metal wannabe, but it’s is different is so many ways. There is a better storyline in Critical Depth, and well, its underwater. Maneuvering with submarines rather than cars is a totally different experience. That’s enough proof for me that it’s an original game. "

Critical Depth is a very enjoyable action game. It takes vehicular combat to a whole new level, literally. Many people may just find this as another Twisted Metal wannabe, but it’s is different is so many ways. There is a better storyline in Critical Depth, and well, its underwater. Maneuvering with submarines rather than cars is a totally different experience. That’s enough proof for me that it’s an original game.

Graphics
The graphics in Critical Depth are just above average. The frame rate is slow and choppy. There can be so many explosions on screen at once that it obstructs your view. This can be very frustrating when chasing after your opponents. The environments can look too empty at times. I know in reality the ocean is vast and enormous, but this is a video game! Another bad thing about the graphics are the little extra fishes, or as I like to call them, “space fillers.” Their only purpose in the game is to just get in your way. The game also could have used some more FMVs. The opening sequence isn’t enough for me.

On the other hand, there are also many good points about this game. The submarine models look excellent. The subs in the game modeled after the real ones are very accurate. There are also many creative subs that look just as good. Another good point is that the subs’ movements through the water look very smooth and realistic. If you ever saw a sub move through water, you wouldn’t know the difference between the two. The missiles and torpedoes that you shoot from your submarine also look and move realistically. What can be more enjoyable than watching your heat-guided missile chase down an enemy sub? Not much.
Rating: 6/10

Sound
The sound in Critical Depth is pretty good. The menu music is only average. You really just don’t notice it since you spend little time in menus anyway. The in-game music is also just average. You never notice yourself saying how good the music is, but you never notice if it’s bad either. But maybe that’s because the sound effects are so large in number. Every time you fire a torpedo, you hear the swoosh as it launches from your sub toward your opponent. Utilize your shield, and you can hear the bzzzzzz as it protects you from enemy fire. There is hardly ever a silent moment while playing this game. That works well for me.
Rating: 8/10

Storyline
Believe it or not, there are storylines behind all of the violence. Every character has their own storyline, but don’t get excited. The storyline is very Twisted Metal-esque. After completing all of the missions, you get a short conclusion of their storyline. What sets it apart from Twisted Metal is that in between each mission, a little bit of the story’s plot is revealed. This is very nice and unique touch. The only thing that reduces this rating is that the endings are just weak attempts of ironic humor. Dramatic endings would have been a lot better than the comical ones.
Rating: 8/10

Gameplay/Control
The controls are decent. Having the shoulder buttons as the firing triggers does take getting used to, but after awhile, it becomes second nature. Turning can become frustrating, especially when trying to find an enemy sub. You turn slowly in every direction looking for your target when you finally realize he’s right above you. But by then, it’s already too late. Moving through the water is easy, but moving quickly isn’t. This fact is very apparent when chasing down an opponent. Other than these two bad spots, the game’s controls are responsive and easily learned.

The gameplay has its pros and cons. The game is VERY difficult when played normally. I took me several tries to get passed the first stage. Collecting “pods” to complete levels is fun and enjoyable. But the best part of the gameplay is blowing up your enemies! What’s more entertaining than destroying enemy submarines with depth charges and laser beams?
Rating: 7//10

Replay Value
Critical Depth has a high level of replay value. Completing the game with each character certainly adds to the replay value, even if the endings aren’t that good. After that, this game is only fun to play against a friend. But that’s not too bad. So get a couple of your buddies over, and have fun blowing up each other’s subs.
Rating: 7/10

Recap
Graphics: 6/10
Sound: 8/10
Storyline: 8/10
Gameplay: 7/10
Replay Value: 7/10

Overall
Overall, this game is pretty good. It reminds me of the good Twisted Metals. The graphics and gameplay have their high points and their low points. The sound effects are awesome, and the storylines are very intriguing, until you get to the endings. There is quite a bit of replay value in this game. I recommend for everyone to at least rent this game. You should find it enjoyable. I did.

Community review by cdbavg400 (November 15, 2004) A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.