Soulcalibur IV (PlayStation 3) review on HonestGamers

Systems > PlayStation 3 > S > Soulcalibur IV > Staff Review

Sign into your user account to view or leave feedback for this review. Don't have an account yet? You can click here to open one. It only takes a minute, and it's free!

Review by Jason Venter
August 18, 2008

Nearly three years after the disappointing (but still very playable) Soulcalibur III released exclusively for the PlayStation 2 platform—to the disgust of the many fans who had made the series a success on alternate consoles—Namco Bandai has finally updated one of its most enduring and critically-acclaimed franchises for the next generation. With polished visuals, several new characters and plenty of time in development, you'd be justified in expecting great things from this latest installment. At the same time, you'd be right to be wary. Since the last game was so underwhelming, what's to stop this newest outing from offering a lackluster repeat?

Absolutely nothing.

Gorgeous though it may be, SoulCalibur IV is unremarkable. The magic that made SoulCalibur and its first sequel such joys to play is absent yet again, resulting in a perfectly good but infrequently memorable fighter. That's confusing when you consider how much work Namco Bandai has clearly put into bottling the familiar magic again. Perhaps the real problem is precisely that: the development team didn't do enough to bring something both compelling and new to the table. Instead, the game is going through the motions... and sometimes not even on the level that we saw from previous entries!

The usual roster of fighters you know and love or loathe has returned, now represented with next-generation polish that makes every breast more jiggly, every muscle more sinewy, every chest hair more... chest-hairy. Sometimes things get absurd, though. How Ivy manages to keep anything permanently covered with her skimpy attire while she bounds around the various arenas is a question for the ages. Some of the new characters also try to ratchet up the sex appeal, with one girl in a wire-frame dress (newcomer Ashlotte) tumbling before the start of each match while the camera swoops down to catch a shot of her panties. Most of the character models are admittedly attractive and I like a bit of bosom or a pair of long legs as much as the next guy—perhaps more, if I'm to be honest—but there will be times when you'll surely grimace and wonder why someone got so much sex in your SoulCalibur.

Speaking of new characters, you'll have to earn them. A handful of them are available right from the start, with a slew of others joining the fight once you meet certain qualifications or purchase them with gold gained by playing through the game's various modes. This same rule applies even to returning veterans, with the initial group seemingly chosen at random. For example, Talim from SoulCalibur II is locked at the start, but Tira (who made her debut in Soulcalibur III) is not. Meanwhile, Zasalamel from that same game must be purchased if you wish to use him and so must Yoshimitsu from the first SoulCalibur. It's puzzling.

Similarly bewildering is the presence of Darth Vader and a Jedi apprentice. Clearly, they're included as some sort of cross-promotion wizardry, but the question I have is “Why bother?” A follow-up query would be “Why didn't they at least make them cool?” Hearing the metal-encased Anakin Skywalker breathe deeply through his respirator is kind of neat, sure, but his move set feels decidedly wimpy and his light saber is hardly the lethal weapon you might imagine. It doesn't feel like he even belongs here, and really he doesn't. Probably the developers didn't want to waste time making him especially spectacular when he won't return for any sequels.

Though some of the newer portions of the roster don't make much sense and are a baffling change for the worse, at least the core combat system is predictably enjoyable. SoulCalibur IV has always featured beautiful combat as warriors clash with blades, spears, staffs and axes—among other things—and that's certainly the case here. You'll should be able to settle comfortably into your familiar routine if you're returning to the fight after enjoying the previous ones, and selectable difficulty levels offer up differing challenges depending on your preferences. This makes things nice and accessible, though of course you still need to work at it if you want to astonish anyone with your mad skills even on the “Normal” level.

When I first began playing SoulCalibur IV, I went that route and it was quite awhile before I even lost a match. The game's “Story” mode is actually pretty short, without many—or even any—battles that will test your prowess. Ring outs are about the only way you'll stumble with any of the better characters, so it's easy to blaze through a few times and earn enough gold to purchase the game's best content. The default “Arcade” mode is meatier both in terms of length and difficulty, while the “Tower of Lost Souls” area is there specifically to kick your butt. You won't progress very far at all through that series of challenges (which are appropriately divided by floor) unless you invest some time in the character creation mode.

Yes, you can again craft custom warriors as you could in Soulcalibur III. The level of tweaking that's possible will probably surprise you, and it only grows as you repeatedly play the main game to unlock new trinkets. From tiaras to boots to skirts and blades, you can modify almost everything about your chosen warrior's attire, plus there are plenty of options for hairstyle and color, not to mention choices regarding which skills should be associated with your custom fighter. If you're the sort who enjoys playing around with such things, you should be quite satisfied with your options here. It's nice that one important element of the previous game has been improved.

Unfortunately, the same thing cannot be said about the overall aesthetics. I was amazed by just how much dark and dreary landscape the artists chose as their focus. The lush scenery in previous games is almost completely absent, with only a few exceptions lingering as if to mock those players who appreciated the previous splendor. The change isn't a technical one, since polygons, textures and lighting are the finest they've ever been. It's all artistic. Aside from a few standout areas that include an icy cavern with mammoths in the background and a tumultuous sea, most of what's here has fallen behind the likes of games such as Dead or Alive 4 or Virtua Fighter 5. The abundance of dank dungeons and lava pits just doesn't have the same grandeur.

The real problem with SoulCalibur IV isn't any one of its minor flaws, though, but rather the way they all come together. Battling through a gauntlet of dreary dungeons and rotting towers populated by giggling girls and armored bodybuilders starts to feel silly instead of intense. That's not really something I ever thought I'd say about SoulCalibur. The series isn't dead yet (many others have recovered from far worse), but Namco Bandai had the chance to make this title a triumphant return to form and instead it's just a flashy but soulless reminder of better days. The definite strengths here—from deep customization to a large character roster to online battles—will keep you playing for a long time if you like what you find and there's no arguing the technical merits of the project, but overall I can't shake the feeling that gamers are being asked to settle. Are you in a settling mood?

Rating
8	SoulCalibur IV is a great example of an extremely polished game that's really good but still falls short of the superior experience that it so easily could have been instead.
Read more about the review rating scale...

Staff reviews represent the opinion of the individual staff member that wrote them and do not necessarily represent the opinion of the site staff as a whole. If you disagree with the contents of this review, you may click to leave feedback on our dedicated forum. Thank you!

HG 2009 Fundraising Progress: $348 / $2500 (14%)

Click to learn about the Fundometer or to advertise.

Game Profile & Content

All

Staff Score (Avg): 8.0 User Score (Avg): 7.0 Press Score (Avg): 6.0
Reviews: 2 Guides: 0 Cheats: 0 Ratings: 0	High Scores: 0 Screenshots: 6 Videos: 0

Title: Soulcalibur IV
Genre: Fighting Action
Publisher: Namco Bandai
Developer: Namco Bandai
Release Date: July 29, 2008
Save: 2048KB
Platforms: X360, PS3

Do you own this game? Register for a free account to track it and other games in your collection!

Voice Your Opinion...

Average User Rating (0 ratings)

Only registered users can rate this game!

PlayStation 3 discussion forums

While you're here...

Tekken 6 is another PlayStation 3 game in the Fighting Action genre that has been attracting activity lately, so you might want to check it out and see what all of the fuss is about!