Killzone: Shadow Fall (PlayStation 4) review "It's easy to praise Killzone: Shadow Fall for being gorgeous, but you'll have to search a bit harder to find other things to love about it."

During its 2013 media briefing at E3, Sony revealed the first footage I ever saw of Killzone: Shadow Fall. The brief interactive demo revealed an absolutely gorgeous scene. A futuristic aircraft of some sort—not quite a transport helicopter, but close—descended toward a magnificent city rising above a picturesque bay. Rivers ended in cascading waterfalls that were mirrored in the glinting reflection offered by towering glass walls.

Watching me work through that segment of the game this past week, my wife remarked that she wished she could live in a place like that. I nodded in agreement. The city as depicted in that brief moment truly is breathtaking, more beautiful than anything I can recall ever exploring on PlayStation 3. It’s a shame that such a spectacular backdrop isn’t more fully explored with exemplary gameplay.

When I purchased Killzone: Shadow Fall, my thinking was that I would definitely want to have a game available to me at launch that said “Hey, this is why you bought a PlayStation 4.” I longed for something beautiful, and that much I received. Textures are superbly detailed, the draw distance is exceptional, and the number of lighting and shadow effects on-screen all at once allows for a greater sense of immersion than perhaps ever before. Put all of that aside for a moment, though, and you’re left with a middling first-person shooter, a collection of generic shooting segments and frustrating exploration sequences made more interesting only by their visual splendor and the (sometimes problematic) use of the DualShock 4’s touch pad.

In Shadow Fall, you are cast as Lucas Kellan, a young ISA soldier with an understandable hatred for the Helghast. The game begins by exploring a key moment from your formable youth and then carries you forward to the present, where you are a hotshot soldier who people call “Sir.” Despite your obvious importance, you like to lead the charge rather than commanding from a safe distance. You’ve been kidnapped by the enemy as the story properly commences, and that’s how you meet a strange young woman who spares your life even though you are her foe. Over the course of the game, you’ll come to question your place in the rapidly-escalating war (as well as that young woman’s place in the same conflict), and you’ll kill a lot of enemy grunts.

For me, the game’s plot only just barely made sense. I’d never played a previous Killzone game and thus didn’t have any real appreciation for a lot of the names that were being thrown around. Shadow Fall reportedly picks up a few decades after the events that brought Killzone 3 to its conclusion, but any allusions to that history were lost on me because I just wanted to jump in and enjoy some time in an unfamiliar world. I was finally able to do so only because the narrative focuses almost exclusively on a handful of characters and any broad themes are easily grasped. None of the events ever felt particularly compelling, but I was at least able to understand who was doing what and why.

Besides working with standard soldiers he will almost never see over the course of the game’s campaign, Lucas controls a special droid device called an OWL, which is where the DualShock 4 touch pad controls that I mentioned a moment ago come into play. Whenever that resource is available, you can swipe the pad in a given direction to switch modes, and then press the L1 button to initiate the desired protocol. In this manner, it’s possible to create a surprisingly effective shield to protect you in a firefight, to aim an electrical pulse, to produce cover fire that distracts adversaries, or to fashion an improvised zip line so that you can safely descend through vertically-oriented areas.



The ability to make that zip line is pretty cool, but it’s not used especially often to any great effect. In one early scene, you’ll need to cross a ravine as you explore a smoldering crash site, and you can also descend on guard towers and catch enemy units by surprise. I liked that mission and found my equipment useful. In another area, you’ll be working along a series of train tracks suspended high in the air. You can move from platform to platform with assistance from your OWL. However, it’s too easy—in that case, and in others—to then circumvent a helpful checkpoint. Shadow Fall presents you with a non-linear world wherein you can complete a variety of objectives in the manner that you prefer, then occasionally punishes you for doing so in an unexpected order.

If the game were a bit simpler, the occasional missed checkpoint wouldn’t pose a problem, but I found that the enemy units were surprisingly capable to the point where it sometimes felt cheap. In particular, they’re good at making their way around cluttered architecture that I often found disorienting. I would head down a corridor, scanning for enemy life and trying not to make my approach obvious, and then suddenly I’d be gunned down by an enemy unit hiding in a passageway off to the side that I had no way to even know existed. There’s no persistent indicator to let you know where threats await, so you really need to pay attention to your immediate and even your more distant surroundings as you advance. If you don’t, it’s easy to serve as the guest of honor at a massacre. You can carry a few adrenaline packs that allow quick revival if you fall and your OWL isn’t out of commission, but you’re able to drag along only a very limited amount of ammo and supplies. Clearly, you’re expected to play smart, rather than simply charging through enemy resistance (though making a run for the next checkpoint is also a viable strategy in some instances).

Thanks to the awkward checkpoint system and the infuriatingly capable AI, Shadow Fall often feels more vindictive than most similar titles do, to the point where some soldiers point and laugh at your corpse. I’m okay with the AI taking a moment to revel in how clever it is, but some sequences also are tedious enough that I’d prefer not to experience them often on my way to something better. There are a number of situations that require you to leap along ledges (sometimes while avoiding speeding trains or whirling mechanical arms), and in some instances you must endure swarms of enemy soldiers for a set period of time. Late in the game, there’s a downright brutal sequence where you’re freefalling through a volatile zone and—as far as I can tell—the best way to get through it is to memorize patterns and hope for the best. I really have no idea how anyone on the development team thought that was executed well enough that it should be included. Elsewhere, I would activate a checkpoint with no remaining adrenaline packs, and then I would almost immediately be gunned down each time I resumed play. In one case, I would rematerialize inside of a cramped elevator bay, looking out toward a bunch of enemy soldiers who were shooting me as if I were a fish in a barrel. In another scenario, I was pinned between groups of enemies on either flank, with wretched cover and nowhere to go that wouldn’t lead me directly into still more enemies.



If you tire of dealing with the campaign, there’s also the expected multi-player mode. There, you play through a series of events called Warzones, which can be created by players too. You’ll go through a series of maps, with various objectives that require you to capture and hold positions or defuse bombs and the like. Multiple classes are available, with a variety of loadouts, and the goal is to do well enough at the varying objectives that your team squeezes out an overall win before advancing to the next map. Along the way, you can earn awards for accomplishing certain feats, such as knifing someone or gunning down a certain number of opponents, but the real reward is practice in the various arenas, so that you can fair better the next time around.

Killzone: Shadow Fall is beautiful. During the PlayStation 4’s launch window, that’s true enough that anyone anxious for a pretty shooter will probably want to give it a shot and then keep playing just to see what spectacular vista lies around each new bend. The multiplayer modes add some welcome longevity to the overall experience, as well. There also are a bunch of trophies that should keep obsessive gamers busy for a long while (including one for surviving through the whole campaign without dying once, which I can’t imagine myself doing in this lifetime). Given the relative lack of gorgeous shooters available for the platform for now, this newest Killzone is a perfectly reasonable stopgap until something more refined comes along. If only it offered a consistently enjoyable experience to match its persistent beauty…

Tweet

Staff review by Jason Venter (November 17, 2013) Jason Venter has been playing games for 30 years, since discovering the Apple IIe version of Mario Bros. in his elementary school days. Now he writes about them, here at HonestGamers and also at other sites that agree to pay him for his words.