Ads are gone. We're using Patreon to raise funds so we can grow. Please pledge support today!
Google+   Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | DS | PS3 | PS4 | PSP | VITA | WII | WIIU | X360 | XB1 | All
Dear Esther (PC) artwork

Dear Esther (PC) review


"Dear Esther is barely a videogame by any conventional sense of the term and approaching it like one will lead to nothing but frustration. But if you're lucky, it clicks, not as a game but as a powerful and moving emotional experience."



What to make of Dear Esther? It's barely a videogame by any conventional sense of the term. Approaching it like one will lead to nothing but frustration. And there is much with which to be frustrated, at least in the early going. The game - and yes, prior statement notwithstanding, we're still going to call it that - is slow out of the gate, plodding, restrictive and scattershot for the better part of an hour. And then - maybe, if you're lucky - it clicks, not as a game but as a powerful and moving emotional experience.

I can't say with any certainty that I "got" Dear Esther. It flits so quickly and easily from the literal to the metaphorical and back again that I can't bring myself to even try to nail it down with any conviction. I think I know what it’s saying (and right or wrong, I have zero intention of revealing my thoughts), but this is something you should prepare yourself for: answers won't come easily. You'll need to be patient, follow the story, look around, pay attention to the narration and the visual clues, reach some conclusions, make some assumptions and then let your gut fill in the blanks.

Following along is a relatively simple task, as Dear Esther is almost perfectly linear. You'll run into a few branching paths as you journey across a deserted, pseudo-magical Hebridean island, but they'll all lead you back to the main trunk in short order, and exploration anywhere off the beaten path is further discouraged--to the point of impossibility--by the extremely limited movement options. You cannot run, jump or interact with anything, so a closed door is closed forever and even the lowest fence might as well be the Great Wall of China. Aside from the occasional leap off a cliffside or stroll into the ocean (both of which will kill you, except not), you will go exactly where the game wants you to and nowhere it does not.

It's a sightseeing tour, really, and while that's a bit dull at first (especially when framed by the early disappointment about being unable to actually do anything), once you're into the meat of the thing there are amazing sights to see. The Source engine isn't getting any younger but some of the locales in Dear Esther are nothing short of stunning, the sort of thing you can marvel at as a technical accomplishment, a contextual curiosity and just for the sheer beauty of it. "Magnificent" is almost an understatement.

The same can be said for the brooding, melancholy soundtrack that fades in and out over the detailed ambient audio as you progress through the game. That's worth the price of admission entirely on its own. Just as important and perhaps more so, the narration that drives the game is every bit as strong - sharp, clear and, for those living on my side of the pond, British enough to give the story a touch of the exotic. It reminds me very much, in fact, of Richard Burton's 1978 telling of the War of the Worlds, particularly as the climax approaches; it's committed, serious and very effective.

Yet as good as it is, Dear Esther isn't actually "fun." It packs a hefty emotional impact - I was fully drawn in by the halfway point and may have even teared up just a bit at the end, without even being entirely sure why - but at no point can I say I was having fun. Despite the apparently randomized nature of the narrative (each trigger point plays one of multiple possible audio clips) I also feel no particular compulsion to play it again; as good as the writing and narration are, hearing the same story told in different ways doesn't strike me as an overly compelling proposition, at least in the short term. Maybe someday, when the edge has dulled, I'll try it again.

It's also fairly short, about two hours on the outside and significantly less if you hustle, a brevity that some people have treated as a complaint but that I'm more inclined to see as a positive attribute. Dear Esther is a slow burn and almost entirely non-interactive, and it would be easy for a game of this nature to overstay its welcome, a fate it fortunately manages to avoid.

In many ways, a review is nothing more than a judgment of whether or not a game achieves its goals. By that measure, I think Dear Esther succeeds. It frames a gripping story in new and unusual ways, and in a more meta sense it provides a brief, early glimpse at some of the things that might be possible for the medium of videogames, beyond mere games. It's not for everyone - something this determinedly niche is hardly for anyone - and as a game, it offers almost nothing. But as a vicarious fever dream that inspires thought and stirs emotion, it's a unique and wonderful thing.

Rating: 8/10

Malygris's avatar
Freelance review by Andy Chalk (February 14, 2012)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by Andy Chalk
Gas Guzzlers Combat Carnage (PC) artwork
Gas Guzzlers Combat Carnage (PC)

Gas Guzzlers: Combat Carnage is a really, really good game, and you're missing out on it.
Hard Reset (PC) artwork
Hard Reset (PC)

Hard Reset isn't quite able to live up to the high standards of mayhem set by Serious Sam and Painkiller, but it gets enough right to be a lot of wrist-snapping fun.
Jurassic Park: The Game (PC) artwork
Jurassic Park: The Game (PC)

Fortunately, such exploration scenes are relatively few and far-between and there are no time constraints or other pressures rushing you along, so you won't be punished for awkwardness or missteps. What you will be punished for, at least once in awhile, is blowing the QTEs. But this actually turns out to be one of the ...

Feedback

If you enjoyed this Dear Esther review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
zippdementia posted February 14, 2012:

Great review. Dear Esther is one game I wanted to try out but can't (I think it's PC only) and it's been difficult to determine whether it was art or just bad art. I think you lean towards the former, but do so without sacrificing a logical look at the product.
board icon
Malygris posted February 14, 2012:

Dear Esther is a game that's really meant to be discussed rather than reviewed. There's not much point in talking about gameplay, so all that's left are the environments, which I think we can all agree are fantastic, and the story. I've seen a few reviews accept it as literal tale of a man on an island, but I'm not sure I buy that.

In the first 30 minutes or so of "play," was ready to dismiss the whole thing as an overblown nothing. But it captured me, and I'm still thinking about it. And I think I may end up replaying it sooner than I expected.

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

Info | Help | Privacy Policy | Contact | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2014 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Dear Esther is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Dear Esther, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.