Game Boy :: Genesis :: NES :: Sega CD :: SNES :: TurboGrafx-16 :: Complete System Listings

Mystery Stories review

Game: Mystery Stories
Platform: DS
Genre: Adventure (Puzzle)
Developer: Cerasus Media

Staff review by Gary Hartley

June 20, 2009

Mystery Stories may try and trick you with its promises of story-based noir trickery and detective shenanigans, but don’t you let it! We’ll get to the point with haste today; there's an overlaying plot that details the hunt for missing Mayan treasure and, strictly, does have you trotting through a series of exotic locations like the trusty back-of-the-box blurb faithfully promises. It’s true that the adventures of journalist Michelle Deanfield are what ultimately links things together, but what it actually links up isn’t exactly clear at first glance.

To clear that up, Mystery Stories is a game where you’re presented with a static screen that you’re most often allowed to roam the camera around. The room's cluttered with all manner of junk and it’s your job, as a roving reporter in the midst of solving a serious crime, to locate and liberate heaving piles of random junk. Just because.

The first screen presents a landing jetty located before an expansive hotel. Here, you’ll need to search the cluttered wooden platform, small stretch of beach and the hotel’s front. Too big to fit on the one screen, you can scroll your point of view around to take the location in sections. This will help as you search feverously for such vital items as sun cream, a bra, and a small collection of empty bottles.

It starts simplistic, and though a change of tone would make for a more interesting read, you’re not getting one. There’s an ever-present time limit enforced and if you decide that random screen stabbings would be more productive than actually searching for the treasured items you seek, then you're penalised by having a sliver of this time evaporate. This would be quite the penalty if the time limit was small enough to cause panic; it’s not. You have fifteen minutes to complete each stage, which each take approximately three or four to normally polish off. There’s often special stipulations to meet, which does go some way into mixing things up. In this first stage, you need to load a camera with film, which amounts to finding a roll of film tucked beneath the aquaplane’s window and dragging it onto the camera sitting precariously at the lip of the rickety wooden jetty.

Other stages present the same general idea with differing ways to accomplish it. Some levels show you a monotone picture of the objects you seek, and ask you to search for their likeness, while others might present a drip feed of clues and ask you to figure out what the game wants you to find. Some drape the screen in darkness and your viewpoint is substituted with a flashlight beam, and some call out what you need to find in selective batches. The weakest version is where instead of any kind of visual prompt, you’re given a sound effect and asked to link the item with the noise. Sometimes, this works fine, but not when something like a trumpet is given a noise like a saw cutting wood when there’s also a saw sitting smugly on screen.

The kooky plot keeps the locations changing, but there’s a lot of taking in the same sights over and over again. Appreciated touches like each level concealing a hidden sun template that, when discovered, offers a stock of hints, such as highlighting a hidden object or freezing your over-generous clock, suffer from this. The sun’s location never changes so once you’ve found it in one hot-spot, you’re free to stock up on helping hands every time you revisit the cracked location. Which will be a lot.

You’re taken from messy museums to crumbling Aztec ruins to guerrilla outposts complete with unguarded machine gun nests. The cast do their best to provide tenuous links along the way, but some way into the game, the writers obviously concluded that trying to keep a serious narrative running would be pointless. It would be, especially on top of being told in-game that you can continue no further with your adventure until you retrieve a seriously soggy muffin form the aquatic depths while partaking in a romantic deep sea dive, allowing the google-loving professor of history to be kidnapped from your boat. By villains who can, apparently, teleport at will.

Stages see you try and free inept police officers after they lock themselves in jail by collecting a series of items he tries to combine into a means of escape (including his homemade bomb constructed mainly out of pickles) or helping Deanfield collect her scattered underwear from a hotel room. These sections are played out with photographs of actors that probably didn’t know just how stupid they were about to be made to look, but the goofy spin is often appreciated.

Mystery Stories’ biggest problem is how it seems to want you to believe it’s something more than a game that presents you with a cluttered room then asks you to point out semi-hidden items with your stylus because, as far as games of this ilk go, this title is a competent and sometimes enjoyable take. The story mode never seems to end and its lifespan is constantly and artificially extended with ceaseless reliance on recycling old haunts, begrudgingly taking you to new locations only when it really, really has to. It’s not going to be a game you sit down for marathon sittings, but for something you can whittle away a few minutes on without needing to ever really turn your brain on for, it’s perfect. But the bottom line is that it’s a game about finding hair brushes and boots in a jumbled screen full of junk and even though it does a competent job at being a game about finding hair brushes and boots in a jumbled screen full of junk, there’s only so many times you can stare at the screen in the desperate search of a tea cup before you need to stop and re-evaluate your life.

More Reviews by Gary Hartley
	Labyrinth X (Xbox 360) Trial and error so tedious, it even takes the gleam off barely-covered anime tits.
	Spec Ops: The Line (PlayStation 3) Come suffer alongside me. You'll thank me for it.
	Super Black Bass 3D (3DS) Too clusmy to be a sim. Too slow to be arcade. Too ugly to get a second look.

Feedback

If you enjoyed this Mystery Stories review, you're encouraged to leave feedback and talk about it with members of the site's community. You don't even need an HonestGamers account to get involved in the discussion. Please remember to keep your comments respectful and on-topic or they may be deleted by a moderator. Thank you for your understanding!

comments powered by Disqus

© 1998-2013 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Mystery Stories is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Mystery Stories, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors.