Patreon button  Steam curated reviews  Facebook button  Twitter button 
3DS | AND | IOS | PS3 | PS4 | VITA | WIIU | X360 | XB1 | All

totally styling Defiant Light ad

Catherine (PlayStation 3) artwork

Catherine (PlayStation 3) review


"A piss the bed nightmare if there ever was one."


Itís weird how playing a lot of one particular game can affect your mind. Itís there when you close your eyes, it mingles with your dreams, and your thoughts just seem to pass through the gameís perspective. This is actually called the Tetris effect, coined when people played a lot of Tetris and couldnít help but think about shapes for the time afterwards. They would ponder over their plans for the day and it would feel like T and L shaped blocks forming in their head.

Vincentís case is a little more severe. The game he often plays on his local pubís arcade cabinet has manifested itself as a reoccurring nightmare of his. Itís a puzzle game about climbing towers of cubes, a frustrating bout of spatial reasoning sure to linger in anyoneís thoughts long after setting the controller down. But in the nightmare, the blocks collapse from beneath Vincent, and if he doesnít climb fast enough heíll end up on the morning news. As a corpse.



Men are dying in their sleep, and thereís a rumor going around town about a witchís curse that punishes unfaithful boyfriends and husbands. Those who survive the nightly ordeal canít seem to recall what they dreamt about, but as the deaths become more frequent, people begin to worry.

With nothing but his polka dot boxers and pillow, Vincent must rely on his intellect to take on each horrific assemblage of cubes. He can only hop up the distance of one cube at a time, so the fundamental idea is to quickly create makeshift stairways by pulling and pushing blocks into place. Pulling them from the tower would naturally cause it to collapse, but it wonít. Just as long as the edge of a cube is touching another cube, nothing will fall-- physics be damned.

This is the rule you live by in the nightmare world, and being clever with it is immensely satisfying, though it does take some getting used to. It doesnít help that some of the trickier puzzles are early on, making it awfully frustrating at first even on friendlier difficulties. You might just end up staring helplessly at a massive wall of cubes, your thoughts becoming one with Vincentís Ė ďFuuuuuuuck.Ē

Whatís more frustrating is that Vincent hasnít even cheated, so what gives? Heís in a steady relationship with his girl Katherine, and the nightmares didnít take hold of his life until she started hinting at marriage and kids. Now, heís scared of commitment, scared of responsibility, and scared of entering the next stage of his life. But heís not scared of the rumors, because heís simply not the cheating type.

Okay, so he did cheat, and hey -- donít judge. Have a few drinks and try to say no to the girl of your dreams when she asks to go home with you for the night. Vincentís one night stand is the result of his indecisive state of mind, and Catherine, a seductive free spirit, swooped in when he was most vulnerable. Sheís provocative, playful, a complete opposite to Vincentís down to earth and workaholic girlfriend . Sheís an escape, and also a little insane (super kinky, no doubt).



Distraught and regretful, he immediately confides in his closest friends at the bar, which amounts to the other playable part of the game. Here you order drinks and get relationship advice from your buds, and talk to other patrons. Although this segment is incredibly chill and has the wonderful vibe of Shigenori Soejimaís character design, it doesnít compliment the frantic puzzle dreams all that well.

Conceptually, itís very cool, meeting other men at the bar who also attend the puzzle ritual each night. They all appear as sheep in the nightmare, herded there to confide in each otherís sins and to take on the trials set before them. You can save these dudes and their relationships by cheering them up either at the bar or in the dreams, but some will lose their way. Instead of showing up for drinks the next night, you might see their bed ridden corpses on TV.

But their problems amount to just a few lines of dialogue each night, straightforward stuff about leaving their partners and losing passion. And Vincentís available dialogue options are in fact very repetitive, too. If you play as the good guy, youíll be shouting ďCome on, donít give up!Ē for the gameís entirety. And if you choose to be more promiscuous, well, nothing really changes at all.

Itís off putting because the game throws choice at you in all sorts of cool ways, but thereís no pay off. You can text Catherine when at the bar and tell her to leave you alone, or ask her for ďPIX NAO!!!1!!Ē Ė but Vincent will continue to meet with her and act shady around his girlfriend regardless. He just mopes about, ashamed of his actions, and does nothing about them. After days of nothing interesting occurring, Catherine can feel like itís not worth the frustration of its puzzles.



By the time this is realized, however, you may have gotten pretty good at them. The stages become addicting, and new block types are introduced every night. Slippery ice blocks, spike trap blocks, crumbling blocks, bomb blocks. Strangely shaped towers of blocks, powerful items that change blocks, enemies that compete with you on your blocks. The frustration fades, and pushing and pulling begins to feel nice, like the cubes are sliding across your thoughts. Tetris Effect!

When the love triangle reaches its climax, Catherine approaches the balance it was after from the start. Beautifully animated cutscenes render all of Vincentís most awkward, ďoh shit oh shit oh shit!Ē moments, and hilarious close calls between the two girls heís seeing. These daily life stresses then become the boss stages, faster paced climbs where a giant monstrosity grabs at your heels. Your girlfriend in zombie form, towering over you, stabbing at you with a kitchen knife. A piss the bed nightmare if there ever was one.

Saying that structure drives its message home gracefully , though, would probably be giving it too much credit. Between dream land and slamming cups of sake down at the bar, approaching the ending of Catherine seems to simply move towards the thinly veiled question of blonde or brunette? And while there are numerous endings to the game, they are simply light hearted shots of fanservice and comedy.

Instead, the experience is, really, just a good bro talk. That maybe itís easy to act the white knight when youíre never given the opportunity to be anything else. And how overcoming fears, more than the topic of dealing with relationships, is the real issue here. Vincent is 32 years old, and heís terrified. Not of women or marriage, but of leaving a part of him behind and becoming an adult, a relatable and prevalent phase among men today. Itís something to think about after completing Catherine, something to think about with blocks.

Rating: 7/10


holdthephone's avatar
Featured community review by holdthephone (August 21, 2012)

A bio for this contributor is currently unavailable, but check back soon to see if that changes. If you are the author of this review, you can update your bio from the Settings page.

More Reviews by holdthephone
Grandia II (PlayStation 2) artwork
Grandia II (PlayStation 2)

Hundreds of encounters end in a single spell cast, and that is a fact.
Rise of the Tomb Raider (Xbox One) artwork
Rise of the Tomb Raider (Xbox One)

Enjoy it before it starts looking old.
Dragon's Dogma (PlayStation 3) artwork

Feedback

If you enjoyed this Catherine review, you're encouraged to discuss it with the author and with other members of the site's community. If you don't already have an HonestGamers account, you can sign up for one in a snap. Thank you for reading!

board icon
zippdementia posted August 21, 2012:

Awesome review, Holdthephone. I've read a lot of reviews for this game and yours is the only one that found a nice balance between explaining the puzzles and the premise, and you do it in half the space as most. I'm impressed. Also, summing Catherine up as a "bro talk" goes completely along with everything I've surmised about the experience.
board icon
holdthephone posted August 21, 2012:

Thanks, it was an oddly structured game to write about. And I wish I had seen this beforehand:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCUT7Jrr6dE
board icon
zippdementia posted August 22, 2012:

That was incredibly engaging. I didn't know you could do head-to-head on Catherine.

You must be signed into an HonestGamers user account to leave feedback on this review.

Policies/Ethics | Contact | Advertise | Sponsor Guide | Links

eXTReMe Tracker
© 1998-2016 HonestGamers
None of the material contained within this site may be reproduced in any conceivable fashion without permission from the author(s) of said material. This site is not sponsored or endorsed by Nintendo, Sega, Sony, Microsoft, or any other such party. Catherine is a registered trademark of its copyright holder. This site makes no claim to Catherine, its characters, screenshots, artwork, music, or any intellectual property contained within. Opinions expressed on this site do not necessarily represent the opinion of site staff or sponsors. Staff and freelance reviews are typically written based on time spent with a retail review copy or review key for the game that is provided by its publisher.